Let
Us Make Man - Rabbi Yosef Benarroch on Parshat
Bereishit
Click here for a printable PDF version of this article
By Rabbi Yosef Benarroch,
Teacher and Rabbi
of Conversion Program, Midreshet B'erot Bat Ayin
This week we will begin to read the Torah anew. The opening portion of Sefer Bereishit guides us through G-d’s creation of the world, ending with his crowning glory - the creation of the first man and woman.
Yet, 5770 years after G-d created the world, we are all left scratching our heads asking if it was really worth it. From the inception of the world it seems that human beings “couldn’t get it right.” Adam and Eve were no more than a mere hour in the Garden of Eden when they completely betrayed G-d’s word. Ever since their blunder, we haven’t faired much better. In 5770 years, we have managed to pollute the world, kill countless of people in war, and through greed create huge socioeconomic gaps in our society. What then is so unique about the creation of human beings? Why is the creation of Adam and Eve seen as G-d’s crowning glory in the creation story?
Before I answer that question, I would like to analyze the creation story. In particular I would like to take a closer look at two discrepancies in the text. After every aspect of G-d’s creation, we are told, “And it was good”. When G-d creates the seas, land, and vegetation, we are told that “it was good” (Bereishit 1:9-13). When G-d creates the sun, moon and the stars we are told that “it was good” (Bereishit 1:14-19). When G-d creates the fish and the birds we are told “it was good” (Bereishit 1:20-23). Finally, when G-d creates the animals of the earth we are told that “it was good” (Bereishit 1:24-25).
The only exception to this rule is the creation of humans. After the creation of Adam and Eve we are not told that “it was good.” The question is why? If we are G-d’s crowning glory, the purpose of all of creation, then should we not be entitled to the acclaim of “it was good” that even the worms of the earth received?
In addition to this it would appear that the Torah makes another comparison between human beings and animals that is quite problematic. On the fifth day of creation we are told the following: “And G-d said let the waters be filled with creatures that have life, and let birds fly above the earth… And G-d created the crocodiles and every living creature that moves… and every winged bird after its kind and G-d saw that it was good. And G-d blessed them saying be fruitful and multiply and fill the waters and the seas and let the birds multiply the earth” (Bereishit 1:20-21).
But if that blessing is given to the animals then what makes it so special to human beings? Is the procreation of humans simply to be equated with that of animals? By blessing the animals to be fruitful and to multiply, it would seem in my eyes to cheapen the blessing for human beings.
Which brings me back to the original question; what is so unique about the creation of humans? How, and in what way, are humans different from anything else that G-d created? What makes us greater than the fish, birds, and animals of the earth?
The answer to that question is in one small discrepancy between the way that G-d blesses the animals and in the way he blesses Adam and Eve. When addressing the animals, the Torah simply says, “And G-d blessed them, saying be fruitful and multiply.” G-d does not speak directly to the animals; he merely gives them a general blessing to inhabit the earth. Not so when G-d blesses Adam and Eve. In their case we are told, “And G-d blessed them and G-d said to them be fruitful and multiply."This is the first time in the Torah where there is a direct dialogue between G-d and his creation.
Dear friends, there is one fundamental difference between human beings and all the rest of creation. We are the only part of creation that G-d addressed directly.
What that means, is that to be human is to have the potential to have a personal relationship with G-d. To be human is to be given the freedom to choose to become like G-d. To be human means that our destiny is not fixed through instinct and nature, but in the choices that we make. To be human is to be born with potential that is in our hands to fulfill or squander. By speaking to Adam and Eve directly, G-d was telling them, and all of us as well, that they would have a unique role to decide their fate and the fate of the world.
The commentaries explain that this is precisely the reason why it never says “it was good” regarding the creation of humans. Since humans were created with the unique capacity of freedom to choose between good and bad and thus determine their destiny, it would make no sense to say “it was good” upon their creation. Human beings are the only part of creation that must earn the right to be called good. While everything else created was given that title right from the start, human beings must hopefully earn that accolade at the end of their lives when they part with the world.
Yes we have polluted our environment, we have created wars, and greed gets the best of us. But we have also managed to do some great things. When push comes to shove human beings have shown their remarkable capacity to love and to be kind. History is filled with many great stories and many great people who were able to realize their likeness to G-d and bring tremendous goodness into the world.
It is precisely this dilemma that the Torah captures in parshat Bereishit. The opening book of the Torah empowers us to do good by allowing us to see that we are all created “in G-d’s image.” By speaking to us, and only to us, G-d was sending us a very clear message that we are his special messengers in the world to be holy and to do good if we so choose.